MLB Baseball Gambling Futures
When it comes to betting on 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds, this market always delivers high drama — and even higher payouts. Pitching dominance is hard to sustain over 162 games, which makes MLB futures wagers on this award both risky and rewarding. Right now, Tarik Skubal has separated himself from the field as the odds-on favorite, but the names chasing him are no slouches.
From power arms with filthy stuff to bounce-back vets and breakout studs, the 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds board has more storylines than a full season of “MLB Tonight.”
Past AL Cy Young Winners
This award has a rich history of honoring dominance. From strikeout kings to precision tacticians, winning the Cy Young takes more than just talent — it demands consistency, health, and eye-popping stats.
In 2024, Gerrit Cole reminded everyone he’s still elite with a dominant campaign. Before that, in 2023, Kevin Gausman emerged with a breakout season. Back in 2022, Justin Verlander defied time to take home the honors.
Here’s a quick look at the last 10 American League Cy Young winners:
- 2024: Gerrit Cole (Yankees)
- 2023: Kevin Gausman (Blue Jays)
- 2022: Justin Verlander (Astros)
- 2021: Robbie Ray (Blue Jays)
- 2020: Shane Bieber (Guardians)
- 2019: Justin Verlander (Astros)
- 2018: Blake Snell (Rays)
- 2017: Corey Kluber (Guardians)
- 2016: Rick Porcello (Red Sox)
- 2015: Dallas Keuchel (Astros)
2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds | MLB Futures
- Tarik Skubal -195
- Garrett Crochet +480
- Hunter Brown +600
- Max Fried +1200
- Jacob deGrom +1600
- Framber Valdez +4500
- Carlos Rodon +5000
- Joe Ryan +7500
- Kris Bubic +7500
- Drew Rasmussen +7500
- Bryan Woo +9000
- Logan Gilbert +15000
- Luis Castillo +15000
- Seth Lugo +15000
- Kevin Gausman +15000
- Nathan Eovaldi +15000
- Chris Bassitt +15000
- Clarke Schmidt +20000
- Jack Flaherty +20000
- 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds provided by MyBookie
Tarik Skubal 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds
Tarik Skubal is looking to defend his AL Cy Young Award, and he’s the odds-on favorite right now. The left-hander has picked up right where he left off in 2024, owning a 10-2 record and a 2.15 ERA. He ranks first in the league with 138 strikeouts, and it’s been rare for him to allow any sort of big inning.
Recently, the nation got to see just how dominant he is after shutting down the Twins on Sunday Night Baseball, which gave his odds a noticeable boost. Skubal has kept runs off the board in seven of his 17 starts this season, and he went a perfect 5-0 with just seven runs allowed over 33.1 innings in June. What’s more, his control has been elite — Skubal has walked only 14 batters through 109.0 innings.
As a result, he has paced the Tigers to the best record in MLB, and right now, the Cy Young is his to lose. With the offensive support he’s getting, he should continue to rack up wins. Even as the favorite, he’s still worth the juice.
Garrett Crochet 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds
Garrett Crochet was acquired in the offseason from the White Sox and signed a deal worth nearly $200 million to lock himself in long-term. That investment is already paying dividends for the Red Sox, as the left-hander owns a stellar 2.06 ERA across 109.1 innings. He’s posted a 1.02 WHIP and continues to overpower hitters, logging his fourth double-digit strikeout game of the year.
Even though he’s been dominant, Crochet has been incredibly unlucky in terms of run support. At home in Fenway Park, he’s 0-3 despite carrying a sharp 2.13 ERA. Still, he’s been consistently tough on opposing lineups and holds a 135:31 K:BB ratio that speaks to both his command and swing-and-miss stuff.
In June alone, he allowed just eight earned runs, signaling he’s trending in the right direction as the season grinds on. While the Red Sox are struggling overall, Crochet gives them a chance to win every time he takes the mound. If he keeps this pace, his second half could be massive for both Boston and 2025 AL Cy Young Futures bettors.
Hunter Brown
Hunter Brown has been one of the biggest surprises of the season. He’s consistently going out there and logging quality starts, working deep into games, and rarely allowing baserunners. The 26-year-old leads all qualified starters in MLB with a 1.74 ERA, to go along with a 0.89 WHIP and a sharp 118:28 K:BB ratio across 98 innings.
Brown finished June with an ERA of just 1.19 over five starts, allowing two runs or fewer in each outing. Even more impressive, he’s been putting together quick innings and has shown great command throughout. That efficiency has helped him rack up an 8-3 record while quietly becoming one of the most effective arms in baseball.
With the Astros’ offense heating up, Brown has benefited from early leads and a little breathing room on the mound. As a result, he’s been able to settle in and attack hitters with confidence. The biggest question now is whether the league will adjust — or if Brown continues to dominate well into the second half.
Jacob deGrom
DeGrom is the kind of value play you make now and hope pays off big in the second half of the season. The Texas right-hander has been absolutely lights out, boasting an 8-2 record and a 2.08 ERA. He took a perfect game into the eighth inning against Baltimore and is clearly pitching with elite-level confidence.
Lately, he’s now delivered four straight quality starts and 12 consecutive outings yielding two earned runs or fewer. Through 95 innings, he’s walked just 20 while inching closer to the 100-strikeout mark, and his WHIP sits at a razor-sharp 0.92. Opponents are hitting only .189 against him, and he’ll carry a 2.24 ERA and 87:18 K:BB line into his next start.
With his command locked in and his velocity holding, he’s showing no signs of slowing down. If he stays healthy — and that’s always the key — expect him to be right in the thick of the 2025 AL Cy Young Futures race down the stretch.
Carlos Rodon
The Yankees rotation has been powered by their pair of lefties at the top, and Carlos Rodon has been a major force. He’s been lights out through the first half of the season, consistently giving New York a chance to win. While he sits at 9-5, he likely deserves more wins given the lack of run support he’s received at times.
Even so, Rodon has managed to overcome those tough-luck outings with dominant stuff. He’ll carry a stellar 2.92 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, and a 119:34 K:BB mark over 101.2 innings into his next start. Opposing hitters are batting just .240 and .237 against him the first two times through the lineup, and he’s been highly effective at limiting damage early.
At this point, it would take a strong second half and a few breaks for him to win the Cy Young outright. However, a Top 3 finish is absolutely in play if he maintains this pace. Rodon’s efficiency and command continue to give the Yankees elite-level outings every fifth day. You could do worse betting on Rodon’s 2025 AL Cy Young Futures.
Best MLB Baseball Sportsbooks For 2025
- VIP Program
- Mobile Betting
- Crypto
- Early Lines
- High Limits
- NEW VIP Rewards
- VIP Program
- Crypto
- Live & Mobile Betting!
- Crypto
- Live & Mobile Betting
- 48 Hour Payouts
- 35% Crypto Bonus
- Live Betting
- Mobile Friendly
MLB Tweet Of The Day
Built like the city he reps. @TarikSkubal pic.twitter.com/fKFYGOVt0c
— Detroit Tigers (@tigers) June 30, 2025
Still Value on the Board
While Skubal is surging, this is still a volatile market. Crochet at +480 is closing the gap fast. And Hunter Brown is turning heads weekly with strikeouts and elite metrics.
Meanwhile, guys like Jacob deGrom or Max Fried could flip the narrative if they catch fire late. Don’t ignore the longshots — a few are still within range if they can string together dominant second halves.
More MLB Baseball Futures Lines
- 2025 World Series Future Lines
- 2025 National League MVP Odds
- 2025 American League MVP Odds
- 2025 NL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds
- 2025 MLB Strikeouts Leader Prop Odds
- 2025 MLB Home Run Leader Prop Odds
MLB Futures Betting
MLB futures let you bet on outcomes in the future, hence the name MLB futures. The most common is picking the World Series winner. You can also bet on AL or NL pennant winners or player awards like NL & AL MVP and Cy Young.
For example, a $250 bet on a pitcher at +6000 odds would return $15,250 — that’s $15,000 profit and you’ll get your $250 back.
To summarize, we don’t just cover 2025 AL Cy Young Futures Betting Odds on our handicapping site. We’ll be providing 4* free MLB Baseball plays on the blog all season long, so check out our experts for guaranteed premium & free Baseball picks!
Lastly, register here for a FREE Baseball Betting Account Now for Daily Free Picks & More Special Offers! Please check out our LINKTR.EE!
