NCAA Football Handicapping
When it comes to betting on the 2025 Heisman Trophy Futures, you’re wagering on more than stats. This market blends hype, highlight-reel plays, program prestige, and narrative into one of the trickiest college football futures out there.
While quarterbacks dominate the odds boards nearly every season, recent history reminds us that a wide receiver or even a surprise transfer can steal the spotlight.
With this year’s field stacked with big names and fresh storylines, the Heisman race is already shaping up to be electric.
Heisman Trophy Legacy
The Heisman Trophy has long been college football’s ultimate individual honor, awarded since 1935 to the nation’s most outstanding player. While quarterbacks have ruled the stage, from Lamar Jackson to Caleb Williams, recent winners like Alabama’s DeVonta Smith proved that non-QBs can break the trend.
Looking back, the last decade has been defined by dual-threat arms, record-breaking stat lines, and players who carried their schools into primetime relevance.
That’s what makes betting this award so unique: talent alone isn’t enough — voters want a story.
Last 10 Heisman Trophy Winners
- 2015 – Derrick Henry, RB, Alabama
- 2016 – Lamar Jackson, QB, Louisville
- 2017 – Baker Mayfield, QB, Oklahoma
- 2018 – Kyler Murray, QB, Oklahoma
- 2019 – Joe Burrow, QB, LSU
- 2020 – DeVonta Smith, WR, Alabama
- 2021 – Bryce Young, QB, Alabama
- 2022 – Caleb Williams, QB, USC
- 2023 – Jayden Daniels, QB, LSU
- 2024 – Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado
2025-26 Heisman Trophy Future Betting Odds | Heisman Trophy Futures
- Arch Manning (Texas) +700
- Cade Klubnik (Clemson) +900
- Garrett Nussmeier (LSU) +900
- Jeremiah Smith (Ohio State) +1200
- Carson Beck (Miami) +1800
- LaNorris Sellers (South Carolina) +1800
- Drew Allar (Penn State) +1800
- Ty Simpson (Alabama) +1800
- Julian Sayin (Ohio State) +2000
- Sam Leavitt (Arizona State) +2000
- Dante Moore (Oregon) +2500
- John Mateer (Oklahoma) +2500
- Jackson Arnold (Auburn) +2500
- DJ Lagway (Florida) +2500
- Gunner Stockton (Georgia) +2500
- Jeremiyah Love (Notre Dame) +3000
- Marcel Reed (Texas A&M) +3500
- Kevin Jennings (SMU) +3500
- Austin Simmons (Ole Miss) +3500
- CJ Carr (Notre Dame) +3500
- Ryan Williams (Alabama) +4000
- Miller Moss (Louisville) +5000
- Fernando Mendoza (Indiana) +5000
- Devon Dampier (Utah) +5000
- Bryce Underwood (Michigan) +5000
- Odds provided by MyBookie
2025 Heisman Trophy Handicapping
Arch Manning +700 — 2025 Heisman Trophy Future Betting Odds
As always, 2025 Heisman Trophy Futures bettors will gravitate to the name brand. Manning looks the part, runs in a QB-friendly Steve Sarkisian system, and Texas is priced like an SEC frontrunner. Moreover, the opener at Ohio State sets the stage for immediate “Heisman moments.”
However, the family mantel may still lack a Heisman when this season ends. With only 95 career attempts and two starts, the sample is thin, and every highlight — and lowlight — will be amplified all year. Consequently, these short odds feel more sizzle than steak.
Cade Klubnik +900 — 2025 Heisman Trophy Future Betting Odds
Meanwhile, Klubnik doesn’t have the surname juice, but he might own the stat ceiling. Last season he stacked 3,639 passing yards with 43 total TDs against just six picks, and he adds dual-threat juice that can mirror Jayden Daniels’ 2023 arc. Additionally, if Clemson’s win column ticks up, his résumé pops fast.
Furthermore, the path is friendlier than Manning or LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier dealing with SEC landmines. If the Tigers surge and Klubnik trims mistakes, +900 can age well.
Garrett Nussmeier +900 — 2025 Heisman Trophy Future Betting Odds
On the one hand, Nussmeier’s first year as LSU’s starter delivered 4,052 yards and 29 TDs — solid, not seismic. On the other hand, the market is clearly pricing in a Burrow/Daniels-style Year-2 leap. Therefore, you’re paying for improvement before it happens.
However, that expectation is already baked into this number, crushing the value. In short, the price is short for a player who wasn’t truly in the Heisman frame a year ago.
Jeremiah Smith +1200
Notably, Smith is the first non-QB on the board — and he’s earned it. As a true freshman at Ohio State he posted 76 receptions, 1,315 yards, and 15 TDs, then grabbed Rose Bowl MVP with 187 yards and two scores. Moreover, he swept Big Ten Freshman of the Year and Big Ten Receiver of the Year.
Consequently, a DeVonta Smith-style candidacy isn’t crazy if the Buckeyes roll and he detonates big games. Plus, Ohio State’s talent density makes dedicated doubles tough, keeping his ceiling intact.
Carson Beck +1800
Historically, transfer QBs have owned this award cycle, and Beck fits the blueprint. Just last year, Cam Ward rode Miami’s platform to a finalist trip and the No. 1 NFL Draft slot. Likewise, if Beck clicks early, the counting stats will come.
Interestingly, the past three Heisman winners didn’t even make the CFP, which keeps Beck live even if Miami isn’t elite. If the ‘Canes outperform expectations, his +1800 ticket gets very real, very fast.
Best Place to Bet Heisman Futures
If you’re ready to lock in a Heisman pick, head over to MyBookie. They’ve got competitive odds, fast payouts, and tons of college football props beyond the Heisman — from conference title futures to win totals. It’s the go-to sportsbook for NCAA bettors looking for an edge.
Best College Football Sportsbooks For 2025
- VIP Program
- Mobile Betting
- Crypto
- Early Lines
- High Limits
- NEW VIP Rewards
- VIP Program
- Crypto
- Live & Mobile Betting!
- Crypto
- Live & Mobile Betting
- 48 Hour Payouts
- 35% Crypto Bonus
- Live Betting
- Mobile Friendly
College Football Tweet Of The Day
Know the answer? Drop it in the comments! ⬇️
We’ll share the answer on Thursday 🏆 pic.twitter.com/2TUD9ukauq
— The Heisman Trophy (@HeismanTrophy) August 26, 2025
Final Thoughts: 2025 Heisman Race
At the end of the day, betting the 2025 Heisman Trophy Futures means balancing hype with value. Arch Manning sits atop the board for obvious reasons, but names like Carson Beck or even longshots like Ryan Williams (+4000) and Miller Moss (+5000) could deliver far better returns if the breaks fall their way.
With so many storylines in play, this year’s race has all the makings of chaos — and opportunity.
More NCAA Football Futures Posts On CP
- 2025 CFB National Championship Odds
- SEC Conference Football Odds
- Big 10 Conference Football Odds
- Mountain West Conference Football Odds
- American Conference Football Odds (AAC)
College Football Futures Betting
NCAA futures let you bet on outcomes well before bowl season. Beyond the Heisman, bettors can wager on conference champions, win totals, or College Football Playoff qualifiers. For instance, a $250 bet on a +3500 Heisman hopeful would return $9,000 — that’s $8,750 profit plus your initial stake.
To summarize, we don’t just cover 2025 Heisman Trophy Futures on our handicapping site. We’ll be providing 4* free CFB plays on the blog all season long, so check out our experts for guaranteed premium & free NCAA Football picks!
Lastly, register here for a FREE College Football Betting Account Now for Daily Free Picks & More Special Offers! Please check out our LINKTR.EE!
